Booknotes
by Arthur Spiess
This Booknote is on Cultural
Resource Archaeology by Thomas W. Newmann and Robert M. Sanford. The book
was published by Altimira
Press 2001, and is available in paperback for $24.95. You can call 1-800-462-6420
for more information. This paperback book is an introduction to the process
of doing cultural resource management (CRM) or contract archaeology. It is
written for the advanced undergraduate or graduate student in a CRM course,
but it would be useful for any amateur or professional archaeologist who is
not familiar with the subject. Throughout the book the authors provide an
interesting historical perspective, drawing much of modern cultural resources
management archaeology practice from lessons learned ( often lessons learned
how not to do it) during WPA archaeology of the 1930?s. There is, thus, a
substantial history of archaeology contribution in this book. The book is
in seven chapters with a glossary, appendices and index, and approximately
240 pages long. The first chapter provides background and history, again tracing
modern cultural resources management of government archaeology to history
beginning in the 1930?s. Chapter 2 is an overview of cultural resources management
laws and guidelines, mostly at the Federal level with reference to some variability
among the states. Chapter 3 discusses how to prepare background for CRM archaeology
projects. Chapters 4, 5, and 6 each address the Phase I, Phase II, and Phase
III stages of archaeological work, respectively, with Phase III archaeology
being the most extensive excavation. And Chapter 7 deals with the production
of archaeological reports. Appendix A is a handy reproduction of Federal regulations
and guidelines, and Appendix B is a glossary. Overall, the book would be quite
useful as an introduction to CRM. If I were teaching a cultural resources
management course I would assign it and then also assign particular case studies
for variety. Mostly it is clearly and simply written, but Chapter 2 on laws
and regulations was pretty hard to follow, even for this reviewer who is familiar
with the subject (Upon reflection, I don?t know whether it is possible to
write a clear simple introduction to these laws and regulations). Scattered
throughout the text are occasional pages of examples usually entitled ?What
We Learned From This? where the authors present an experience of theirs that
helped them learn what or what not to do in cultural resources management
archaeology. Some of these anecdotes were useful, and some of them left me
perplexed. By the way, the second author, Rob Sanford, is an Assistant Professor
at the University of Southern Maine and the Department of Geography and Anthropology.
It is nice to have Rob in Maine, and we all hope he can use some of his experience
in teaching cultural resources management archaeology.